Fiverr and Upwork both lost clients, and the ones left pay more

Photo: www.Pixel.la Free Stock Photos, public-domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Desk-laptop-working-technology_(24299511976).jpg
Fiverr now counts 2.4 million active buyers, down from 3.3 million a year earlier, a drop of 25.8%.
What Fiverr reported
In the third quarter, total revenue was $90.9 million, which is 15.8% below the $107.9 million of a year before. Revenue from the marketplace itself, the part where buyers find freelancers, fell 24.7% to $55.4 million. Spend per buyer rose 12.9% to $373 a year, so the buyers who stayed are paying more. Projects at or above $1,000 made up 16% of the gross order amount of completed projects over the past twelve months. Fiverr blamed the fall in buyers mainly on pressure on low-value work and on changes in how people search. It expects the move from search to AI-driven discovery to bring a steeper decline in marketplace traffic through 2027 than it previously expected. Its chief executive, Kaufman, called the changes a "platform transformation". Kaufman says the search era built Fiverr and the AI era is where it intends to lead. Kaufman also said that organic clicks are falling across the web while acquisition costs are rising for everyone who depends on them. The services side of Fiverr grew 3.4% to $35.5 million.
What Upwork reported
Over at Upwork, work tied to AI grew more than 22% from a year earlier in the second quarter. In that group, AI strategy and consulting work grew over 50%. Upwork shares still fell sharply when the company cut its full-year guidance. The chief executive of Upwork, Hayden Brown, said the shortfall came from faster AI automation, a weak labor market and falling Google search traffic. Management also said that around 10% of the work on the platform is exposed to AI-driven shifts. Spending per client hit a record, so the clients who remain appear to be buying bigger jobs. Gross services volume per active client, which is the average amount each client spends, was $5,230, up 5% year-over-year. In the Upwork results, routine tasks like basic writing, translation and simple coding are the ones increasingly automated. Upwork has also built a server that lets AI agents find talent and help manage work on its marketplace. Both firms reported the same pattern, fewer customers spending more each.
What the research says
Olin researchers and a colleague from New York University studied Upwork after the November 2022 release of ChatGPT and found that monthly jobs for writing freelancers declined by 2% and monthly earnings by 5.2%. Designers and other image workers fared worse, with monthly jobs down 3.7% and monthly income down 9.4% after tools like DALL-E and Midjourney appeared. The evidence suggested that more highly skilled workers lost more new jobs and income, though the researchers cautioned that this result is not definitive. The authors stressed that these results only cover the short term effect of AI tools on freelance work. At Fiverr, management says simple tasks are being automated by AI, while the work that remains is more complex and carries more value. Hayden Brown, the chief executive of Upwork, argues that AI splits the market rather than ending it, since clients hire freelancers to finish or fix work started with AI tools. If the research and the earnings point the same way, the lesson is that the cheap, repeatable job is the part of freelancing that software takes first.
A concrete example
For a hypothetical freelance translator who sells cheap jobs through marketplace search, both shifts hit together: software does the cheap jobs, and fewer buyers arrive from search. The same effort then brings in less money each month, though the translator did nothing wrong. A translator who instead delivers a finished, checked document at a fixed price and a clear deadline is selling the work the platforms say is still growing.
What to do this month
Do an honest audit of your recent invoices and mark the jobs that software could now do in minutes, since their price will keep falling. Then build your offer around an outcome a client can describe in a sentence, such as a finished report, and price it as a package rather than by the hour. Do not depend on a single marketplace for discovery, since the search traffic those platforms rely on is shrinking; keep a list of past clients and a simple page that explains what you deliver.
My take
My view is that this is not the end of freelancing but the end of its comfortable middle, where average work at an average price was enough. The numbers show buyers leaving and the remaining buyers spending more, and I read that as a market that rewards trust and responsibility over volume. I would doubt the tidy story that every freelancer can move upmarket, since the research suggests experience alone did not protect people. So I treat these reports as a warning with a direction, not a verdict: build clients who do not depend on search, charge for outcomes, and check the numbers again next quarter.
Sources
- Fiverr International, third quarter 2026 results release (SEC Form 6-K) (2026-10-29)
- The Motley Fool, Fiverr Q3 2026 earnings call transcript (2026-10-30)
- Upwork, second quarter 2026 results release (SEC Form 8-K) (2026-08-10)
- The Next Web (2026-08-12)
- Olin Business School (Washington University), study of generative AI and freelance work (2023-08-24)
This brief passed an automated quality check before publication. Found a mistake? Tell us · Editorial standards
